I appreciate the compassion.
I appreciate the anger at
objectification.
I appreciate the attempt to
bring women back to their own
inner worth.
But I do not agree
that showing one's body
is inherently a fall from some
"sacred core."
You diagnose the illness
perfectly.
Then you prescribe the wrong
medicine.
In trying to escape one prison,
you build another
and call it liberation.
You attack the male gaze,
yet the argument still lets men
define
a woman's relationship with her
own body.
"Don't show your body because
men will consume it"
still makes the man's desire
the centre of the woman's
decision.
Why should a woman's freedom
be determined by the weakness
or lust of the observer?
Women post images for many
reasons,
art, playfulness, politics,
body-reclamation,
aesthetics, preference,
or yes, sometimes validation.
Viewers respond in many ways
too.
Some with respect.
Some with objectification.
Some with both.
The problem begins
when we reject one set of
external judgments
the male gaze, the algorithm,
the culture of consumption,
only to replace them with
another.
A new hierarchy of purity.
Sacredness.
Authenticity.
Suddenly someone else is
certain
of what is "ugly truth,"
what real power looks like,
what a woman should reveal,
and where she should return.
Moral authority can wear the
clothes
of solidarity and lived
experience too.
A woman can be completely naked
and utterly virgin in her
consciousness.
Another can be fully clothed
and completely prostituted in
her mind.
I am suspicious of virtue
imposed through shame,
repression,
or social morality.
And I will never automatically
place
the mind and poetry above the
body
as if one is sacred
and the other somehow lower.
Why do we think the mind is
more sacred than the body?
The body is the visible part of
the soul.
The soul is the invisible part
of the body.
To reject the body in favour of
the poem
is to remain fragmented.
A conscious woman
does not need to choose between
her skin and her intellect.
She owns both.
She can use both.
And she is attached to neither.
A woman is not sacred
because her body can create
life and her virtueness.
She is sacred
simply because she is alive.
Hiding is not automatically
freedom either.
A woman can post a fully
covered photograph
and still be desperately
seeking validation.
Another can post a sensual
photograph
without needing anyone's
approval at all.
The action does not reveal
consciousness.
The inner state does.
So:
Don't post your body because
men want it.
Don't hide your body because
morality fears it.
Don't turn your body into
currency.
Don't turn modesty into another
currency either.
Be conscious.
Then the body is neither
temptation nor prison.
It is simply yours.
Coming home does not mean
becoming someone new.
It means dropping who the world
told you to be.
Society, media, parents,
lovers, partners,
they all teach us how to market
ourselves.
What to reveal.
What to hide.
What makes us desirable,
respectable, powerful, pure.
But home is the space of
absolute innocence
that existed before any
marketing began.
That is why late night poem we
almost deleted
felt like home.
Not because poetry is more
sacred than the body,
but because it was born in
isolation
free from the desire for an
audience.
An act of pure meditation,
not performance.
But the same can be true of a
photograph.
The photograph is not
automatically a performance
because it contains skin.
The poem is not automatically
meditation
because it contains pain.
Neither the covered body
nor the naked body
can tell us where consciousness
is.
Only the person living within
it knows.
If we escape the prison of the
crowd
only to enter the house of a
saviour
who tells us what true
liberation should look like,
we have not become free.
We have only changed masters.
Freedom asks something quieter:
Not to obey the crowd.
Not to obey the gaze.
Not to obey the morality that
fears us.
And not even to obey
someone else's idea of
liberation.
But to become conscious enough
that whether we speak or remain
silent,
cover ourselves or reveal
ourselves,
write a poem or post a
photograph,
the choice is finally our own.